Updated on Aug. 26, 2024
Coffee is an essential part of the morning routine, but do you have the best drip coffeemaker at home to start your day right? Our pros tested 10 of the most popular models.
Our editors and experts handpick every product we feature. We may earn a commission from your purchases.Learn more.
Everyone wants to make sure they have the best coffeemaker on their counter. To help you out on your quest, our Test Kitchen experts tested 10 of the most popular models to find the best drip coffeemaker options on the market.
Maggie Knoebel in our Test Kitchen took the lead with this test. Not only is Maggie an expert here at Taste of Home, but she also worked as a cafe manager and barista for five years. If anyone knows coffee, it’s her!
Pros:
Cons:
Specs
For less than $100, you can get a phenomenal basic coffee maker: the Braun Brew Sense Coffee Maker.
“I feel like comparing this to a well-made German car,” says Maggie of this coffeemaker. The Braun Brew sense is simple and streamlined with all of the features coffee fanatics need and no frivolous extras. Its sleek appearance makes it a welcome addition to any at-home coffee bar.
With this Braun coffeemaker, you can adjust the brew strength of your favorite coffee as well as the temperature of the warming plate; that means folks that like lava-like brews can keep their pot piping hot before they add a splash of creamer. You can also program this coffeemaker so your preferred brew can be ready as soon as you are.
Pros:
Cons:
Specs
In the words of Maggie, “Buckle up because we are in coffee town and this Breville coffeemaker is our mayor.” This Breville Precision Brewer Coffee Maker is a definite favorite in the Test Kitchen.
This Breville model is our favorite high-end drip coffeemaker because it does it all. Not only can you brew a standard pot of coffee, but you can also brew single-serve coffee, pour-over coffee, cold brew or iced coffee. This one coffeemaker does all of that, and it does it well.
Before you even brew your first cup, Breville sets caffeine-fiends up for success with its water test. Use a test strip to calibrate the machine to your tap’s chemistry. Once you’ve done that, you can let the coffeemaker do the work with all its preset options including a Gold setting that makes a pot according to Specialty Coffee Association specifications (fancy!).
But if you’re particular about your brew, you can create your own brewing preset; this is a game-changer for coffee aficionados. And with a child-safe lock, you never have to worry about anyone fussing with your precise coffeemaker configurations. With an advanced machine like this, you might be frequenting your favorite cafe a bit less (but be sure to up your coffee subscription to make up for it).
Pros:
Cons:
Specs
Can’t decide between a single-cup brewer and a traditional coffeemaker? You don’t have to with the Hamilton Beach FlexBrew Trio Coffee Maker.
This countertop appliance can be used to make full posts of coffee, single cups and even travel mugfuls. With three different settings, you may think this machine might be three times as complicated, but Maggie says that this Hamilton Beach coffeemaker was one of the simplest to operate: “This unit is labeled well and is really user friendly.”
With just a touch of a button you select the size and the brew strength you desire. There are also other great basic features like a programable brew so you can set the pot to be ready when you meander into the kitchen.
This multi-tasking brewer does take up more counter space than traditional coffeemakers, but it combines the functionality of several appliances.
Pros:
Cons:
Specs
Just because you’re short on counter space doesn’t mean you have to sacrifice a good cup of coffee. With the Krups Simply Brew Digital Drip Coffee Maker, you can make your morning cuppa and still have room to prep a quick breakfast.
This model is relatively basic, but it still makes a great cup of joe. Maggie compares the flavor that this appliance creates to French press coffee.
While streamlined, Krups Simply Brew coffeemaker does have a few features our Test Kitchen enjoyed, like the hot plate to keep your pot warm for up to two hours. You can also customize the brew strength with the touch of a button. There’s also a reusable filter basket included with this model so you never have to worry about having to keep filters in the house. One more bonus: The pot is dishwasher-safe. Toss it in after each brew to keep your coffee tasting its best.
Pros:
Cons:
Specs
For a no-frills cup of joe to kick-start your morning, fire up the OXO Brew. This machine is outfitted with features our pros loved along with a thermal carafe.
Now, what makes a thermal carafe so special? This double-walled coffee pot is insulated so it keeps coffee hotter for longer without the use of a warming plate. The streamlined stainless steel pot also looks nice in any modern kitchen.
Beyond the carafe, this OXO coffeemaker gained high praise from Maggie. “You can tell this machine was made with the customer in mind,” she says. That means easy-to-remove, dishwasher-safe components, intuitive controls and a drip-free valve that lets you pour a cup of joe before the pot is done brewing. Also, an indicator light automatically comes on after every 90 brews so you’ll know when it’s time to clean the coffeemaker.
While this is a traditional coffeemaker with a carafe, you can also brew smaller servings right into your favorite mug. Just swap out the large filter basket for the small one (both are included in the box). Select the smaller batch button and you’re ready for a single serving.
In this test, Maggie and our team tested each model with these standards in mind. Our pros were also sure to avoid these common coffee brewing mistakes.
Maggie made dozens of pots of coffee for this test (and kept our office well-caffeinated). Check out which ones are Test Kitchen-Preferred.
Kettles are just the tip of the testing iceberg! Our Test Kitchen is constantly testing kitchen gadgets, cleaning gear and delicious food, looking for brands that deserve the right to be called Test-Kitchen Preferred.
If you’re looking to outfit your kitchen with a few new appliances, be sure to check out these tests:
